This blog covers the following aspects related to M&A.
1. Conducting due diligence for evaluating Target comp
2. Performing risk assessments for M&A
3. Valuation of Target company and submitting the bid
4. Negotiations between acquiring company and the target company
5. Obtaining Statutory approvals for M&A
6. Managing Post-merger Integration
1. Conducting due diligence for evaluating Target comp
The top 5 key aspects of each function are listed below.
Key Areas to Evaluate | Top 5 aspects |
Sales and Marketing | 1. Demand potential of products of the target company 2. Market share (Global & local) of different products 3. Channel partners & strength 4. Relationships with high-value customers, channel partners 5. After-sale service infrastructure |
Technology
| 1. Know how capabilities & Intellectual property 2. Manufacturing Infrastructure & Capacity and Process Capabilities 3. Supply chain strengths 4. The quality infrastructure in the plants/factories/Vendors 5. IT Infrastructure/ERP |
Financial | 1. Past five years & next five years projections for Sales, market share, cash flows & profitability 2. Fixed costs 3. Long-term Liabilities 4. Audit reports (Statutory, Internal, cost etc) 5. Physical Inventories & Receivable status |
Management | 1. Risk assessment (Financial, market, operations & legal) 2. Leadership team profile, 3. Qualification of senior management, 4. Industry Standing /reputation 5. Corporate governance |
Human resource | 1. Key positions manning & Organisation hierarchy/levels, 2. Versatility & competency assessment 4. Retirement age, Pension-at different levels 3. Payroll, emoluments 5. Industrial relations & long-term agreements with unions |
Legal | 1. Statutory non-compliances 2. Legal cases in courts, including consumer cases 3. Litigations status in India 4. Statutory demands 5. International level-disputes, arbitration, court cases |
2. Performing risk assessments for M&A
The top 5 assessment areas are as under:
· Market risks
· Financial risks
· Operational risks
· Legal risks
· Human resource-related risks
3. Valuation of Target company and submitting the bid
Choosing the valuation option method out of the few available as below and determining the most appropriate one:
· Comparable company analysis
· Comparable transaction analysis
· Discounted. Cash flow analysis
· Assets-based valuation.
· Industry-specific valuation
Other -Qualitative factors include Market share, Brand value, Intellectual property,
Management expertise, Revenue growth, Strategic Synergy advantages
4. Negotiations between acquiring company and the target company
A team of competent persons from the acquiring company needs to evaluate the following for determining the financial proposal depending on the size and type of target company:
§ Stock purchase option
§ Assets purchase option
§ Both
§ Any alternative
Further below aspects need to be factored in developing a purchase bid.
· Purchase price and taxes
· Payment terms -down payment and progressive based on milestones
· Exclusions
· Key manpower to be acquired from the target company
· Labour contracts/union agreements
· Covenants
· Employee emoluments, transfers, retirement age, and pension matters
· Regulatory approvals timelines and responsibilities
· Integration plans between acquiring company and the target company and change management
· Communication links /contact persons for resolving conflicts/issues till complete M&A occurs
· Timelines for completion of M&A
5. Obtaining Statutory approvals for M&A
Depending on the type of the bidding company & nature of transactions, a few of the below applicable approvals may be necessary.
· Approval from SEBI, for listed companies, in matters related to the substantial acquisition of shares.
· RBI approvals in case M&A involves foreign investment or cross-border foreign exchange,
· Sector-specific approvals (from bodies like NCLT, TRAI, IRDA etc as applicable
· Tax authorities vis a vis Capital Gain tax, transfer pricing, indirect taxes
· Competition Commission approval to prevent anti-competition activities under The Competition Act 2002
· Court approvals, as necessary, related to convening of meetings of shareholders, creditors, etc
6. Managing Post-merger Integration
Once the M&A negotiations are complete and both acquiring and target companies decide to merge, the following activities must be performed for a smooth transition.
· Executing M&A agreements
· Getting statutory approvals speedily
· Communicating key highlights of M&A to all stakeholders ( Vendors, channel partners, key OE customers, business associates, and employees, at the appropriate time
· Meeting identified stakeholders by key people
· Integrating staff deployment with new organization structure
· Reviewing the compensation structure of the acquired company
· Retaining talented employees of the acquired company
· Assigning new roles in the merged entity
· Improving methods in all functions, as required for enhancing productivity, quality business, reducing costs and market share increase :
· Meeting key vendors along with key professionals from the acquired company
· Meeting key Channel partners and key customers along with key professionals from the acquired company
Activities(including unethical) that can affect the business adversely
· Due to diligent (DD) checklists not being exhaustive and DD performed by individuals rather than cross-functional team
· The risk assessment process is not comprehensive and not performed by specialists.
· Incomplete or & Inaccurate information gathering by the DD team on for arriving at valuation on past financial performance and future projections for five years
· Incorrect Assumptions on qualitative management aspects, long-term liabilities, technical strengths, Sales growth potential/market share projections, synergy advantages, etc.
· inadequate market intelligence on competition bids/strategy
· Collusion amongst key members acquiring & target company
· Compromising on statutory requirements leading to delays
· Not preparing the organization for change management
· Pursuing a biased approach while dealing with the erstwhile employees of the target company acquired
·